Price & Purchase
Process & Packaging:
Let me start off this review with complete honesty. I am not that
big of a Too Faced fan for a variety of reasons. I have some of their products,
but they are not my favorite brand. This year I decided to invest a bit of
money into some of their holiday items for my personal use and for review. I
purchased 5 holiday items, 4 of which are limited edition and one that is a
permanent item. I purchased The Best Year
Ever ($49), Just Peachy Mattes ($45), I Want Kandee Candy Eyes ($45), Boss Lady
Beauty Agenda ($58), Pretty Little Planner ($42). All items were purchased
from either Ulta or Sephora depending on what products were contracted to
either vendor. All products were received in excellent condition and each was
packaged in the innovative, feminine, and whimsical idealism associated with
Too Faced products.
· Just Peachy Mattes – shadows
packaged in a over-sized compact with a clutch type latch; face of the product
adorned in a peach to crème type ombre effect, with gold lettering and gold
edging
· I Want Kandee Candy Eyes – face
packaged in baby pink with gold lettering with an outward beveled top
· Boss Lady Beauty Agenda – eyeshadows
packaged with a baby pink sizeable planner with a zipper that encompasses the
product from top to bottom; planner is made of a “pleather” like material and
contains script lettering printed in gold, similar to the rest of the
collection
· Pretty Little Planner –
eyeshadow packaged in a mint green “pleather” planner with a zipper containing
a gold/brass tassel and lettering similar to the tassel
· The Best Year Ever –
packaging houses three small palettes & a pocket planner; with a little
gold face & a more gold/brass lettering, the packing has detailed chevron
pint all the back and binding of the planner which is made of a “pleather” like
material
Pigmentation & Color
Payoff & Performance:
My evaluation of pigmentation, color payoff & performance is
based on my rather large and gluttonous eyeshadow collection. When I evaluate
these categories I look at several things, including price per gram, other
brands in the same or similar price brackets, and the originality of the
product. For example, I wouldn’t compare Too Faced to let’s say Natasha Denona.
Why? Price per gram, different price bracket and one I consider a luxury brand
and the other is high – end. Different expectation for different levels of
product.
A lot of consumers like Too Faced eyeshadow formula. They find it
particularly useful for every day, practical, work looks, and it is beginner
friendly eyeshadow brand. I think this estimation of the brand’s eyeshadow
formula is true and it’s Chocolate Bar Palette was among the first group of
eyeshadow palettes I purchased. With that being said, Too Faced is notorious for
two issues consumers & beauty experts have complained about over the last
several years: 1) their limited-edition & holiday products are subpar in
quality and 2) they recycle their shadow concepts over and over again. I have
never purchased any of Too Faced’s holiday collection items and the buzz about
this year’s holiday items was highly promoted personally by the brand’s owner
Jerrod Blandino. I purposed myself to buy several of Too Faced’s holiday items
because I wanted to see if the negative evaluations of the brand’s past holiday
items were valid. So, I purchased all the items listed above at full price.
During the evaluation of each eyeshadow palette, it was apparent
to me that the Just Peachy Mattes Palette & The I Want Kandee Candy Eyes
Palette were significantly better quality that the other three items I
purchased. The agenda palette were a pretty average rendering of their patent
varying neutral brown shades with a singular dark shadow pressed with obnoxious
and unusable glitter. Go look at their last several holiday palette, hell, even
their coveted Chocolate Bar Series along with the Sweet Peach Palette contains
a multitude of brown shades with only slight variations that certainly don’t
make a significant color difference when applied to the eye. So, if you like
neutral brown shades, or are looking for a holiday gift for a novice makeup
wearer or a teenager, then the agenda palettes might be worth the investment.
Quite honestly, they scream “recycled gimmick” but I am sure there is a
particular circumstance or personal that would find these palettes both
practical and useful. They are just not useful, practical, or interesting
enough for me and I will probably gift them to my niece.
Now, on a completely different hand, both the I Want Kandee &
Just Peachy Mattes palette are probably the best palettes that Too Faced has
ever produced. The Just Peachy Mattes palette is full of intoxicating colors
which is arranged in an ombre peach color dynamic that is useful for many skin
tones and depths of color. The shadows are creamy in texture and apply evenly
and blend well. Definitely an upgrade in the quality department for this
palette and I would dare to say that this is one of my favorite matte palettes
in terms of texture, wear time, color selection, and brown-girl friendly product.
On to the I Want Kandee palette….In terms of shade selection, the palette is
mediocre, boring and reminiscent of many of Too Faced’s previous neutral brown
palettes. There is nothing new or creative about the shade selection in any
way. However, the quality of this palette far surpasses any of the Chocolate
Bar palettes – hands down. Similar to the Just Peachy palette, the matte
shadows are considerably creamy, dense in color, yet easily blendable on the
eyes. The shimmer shadows are beautiful and pair well with the mattes and the
palette is arranged in a cohesive and sensible way. Both the Just Peachy &
the I Want Kandee palettes are worth the investment if you’re in the market for
shades in these tones.
Overall Product
Presentation:
I
purchased a significant portion of Too Faced’s Holiday Collection. I think all
the products have a place in this competitive market, although some products
are superior to others. The agenda palette are perfect for that teenagers,
college student or just people who like to collect Too Faced’s products. If you
are expecting the agenda palettes to be revolutionary & innovative
products, you will disappointed. The agenda palettes are replicas of Too Faced’s
neutral brown toned shades that are seen in every Chocolate Bar palette,
several of the 9 pan palettes, and even the Natural Love palette. But in Too
Faced’s defense, the concept and idea of the palette is quite genius and is
marketed to young millennials. The packaging is cute, and festive, but also
very gimmicky. If Too Faced laid off the over the top packaging, an market
specific concepts and invested their money in producing quality products time
and time again, then I would be impressed. On the flip side, the Just Peachy
Mattes palette & the I Want Kandee palette speaks to what Too Faced is capable
of: classy, but not over the top packaging, quality shadows, and products that
are not specifically marketed towards millennials.
Rating: 3/5
✭✭✭✰✰